Denny Menholt Honda | Bozeman, MT
Honda HR‑V vs Toyota Corolla Cross
Bottom line: both are practical, efficient subcompact SUVs with available AWD, but the Honda HR‑V pulls ahead on independent safety testing, cargo room behind the rear seats, and roadside coverage, while the Corolla Cross counters with a lower starting price, more horsepower, and the one thing the HR‑V cannot match anywhere in its lineup, a hybrid powertrain. Here is the full breakdown for anyone cross shopping these two around Bozeman.
Honda HR‑V
Toyota Corolla Cross
Jump to a section:
Honda HR‑V vs Toyota Corolla Cross Spec Comparison
| Honda HR‑V | Toyota Corolla Cross | |
|---|---|---|
| Starting MSRP | $26,600 (LX FWD) | $25,235 (L FWD) |
| Gas engine | 2.0L 4 cyl, 158 hp, CVT | 2.0L 4 cyl, 169 hp, CVT |
| Hybrid available | Not offered in the US | Yes, 196 hp, standard AWD |
| AWD available | Real Time AWD on every trim, $1,500 | Optional on gas trims, about $1,300 to $1,450; standard on all hybrids |
| Fuel economy (combined) | 28 mpg FWD, 27 mpg AWD | 32 mpg gas FWD, 30 gas AWD, 42 hybrid AWD |
| Cargo behind rear seats | 24.4 cu ft, 55.1 cu ft with seats folded | 24.0 to 25.5 cu ft gas, 21.5 cu ft hybrid |
| IIHS award | 2026 Top Safety Pick+ | 2025 Top Safety Pick; no 2026 award |
| Basic / powertrain warranty | 3 yr / 36,000 mi basic, 5 yr / 60,000 mi powertrain | 3 yr / 36,000 mi basic, 5 yr / 60,000 mi powertrain |
| Free maintenance program | Honda Service Pass, 1 yr / 12,000 mi, 3 yr roadside assistance | ToyotaCare, 2 yr / 25,000 mi, 2 yr roadside assistance |
| Safety suite | Honda Sensing, standard | Toyota Safety Sense, standard |
Honda HR‑V Trim by Trim Pricing
Toyota Corolla Cross Trim by Trim Pricing
- L FWD$25,235
- L AWD$26,535
- LE FWD$27,565
- LE AWD$28,865
- XLE FWD$30,160
- XLE AWD$31,610
- Hybrid S AWD$29,295
- Hybrid SE AWD$30,615
- Hybrid XSE AWD$33,330
Which Is Cheaper, the Honda HR‑V or Toyota Corolla Cross?
The Corolla Cross L lists about $1,365 under the HR‑V LX in front wheel drive form. The gap holds at the mid trims, where the Corolla Cross LE lists about $835 under the HR‑V Sport, and nearly disappears at the top, where the HR‑V EX‑L AWD lists just $340 above the Corolla Cross XLE AWD. The most telling matchup for Montana buyers: the Corolla Cross Hybrid S, with standard AWD, lists about $600 under an HR‑V Sport AWD.
Which Has More Horsepower, HR‑V or Corolla Cross?
The Corolla Cross, at every level. The gas Corolla Cross makes 169 horsepower to the HR‑V's 158, and the Corolla Cross Hybrid jumps to 196 horsepower. The HR‑V uses one engine across the lineup, a 158 horsepower 2.0 liter four cylinder with a CVT.
Is There a Honda HR‑V Hybrid?
No. This is the clearest split between the two SUVs. Toyota offers three Corolla Cross Hybrid trims, S, SE, and XSE, all with standard AWD. Honda does not sell a hybrid HR‑V in the US. Shoppers who want a Honda hybrid SUV with AWD should look one size up at the CR‑V Hybrid.
Does the Honda HR‑V Have All Wheel Drive?
Yes. Honda's Real Time AWD is available on every HR‑V trim, LX, Sport, and EX‑L, for $1,500. The Corolla Cross offers AWD as an option on its gas trims and makes it standard on every hybrid, so both SUVs can be set up for Bozeman winters and gravel roads.
Which Is More Fuel Efficient, HR‑V or Corolla Cross?
The Corolla Cross. The gas version is rated at 32 mpg combined in FWD form and 30 with AWD, ahead of the HR‑V's 28 FWD and 27 AWD. The Corolla Cross Hybrid widens the gap to 42 mpg combined with standard AWD.
Which Is Safer, Honda HR‑V or Toyota Corolla Cross?
The HR‑V holds the edge in independent IIHS testing. It earned a 2026 Top Safety Pick+, the organization's highest award, under the latest and toughest criteria. The Corolla Cross earned a Top Safety Pick under the 2025 criteria but did not earn a 2026 award. Both SUVs come standard with a full driver assistance suite, Honda Sensing on the HR‑V and Toyota Safety Sense on the Corolla Cross.
How Do the Warranties Compare?
Nearly identical on paper. Both carry a 3 year, 36,000 mile basic warranty and a 5 year, 60,000 mile powertrain warranty. The difference shows up in complimentary maintenance: Toyota's ToyotaCare covers 2 years or 25,000 miles of factory scheduled maintenance plus 2 years of roadside assistance, while Honda's Service Pass covers 1 year or 12,000 miles of maintenance but extends roadside assistance to 3 years. Toyota gives you an extra year of free maintenance, Honda gives you an extra year of roadside coverage.
Which Has More Cargo Room?
The HR‑V, especially against the hybrid. It offers 24.4 cubic feet behind the rear seats and 55.1 cubic feet with them folded. The gas Corolla Cross is close behind the rear seats at 24.0 to 25.5 cubic feet depending on trim, but the Corolla Cross Hybrid drops to about 21.5 cubic feet to make room for its battery pack, so the most efficient Corolla Cross is also the one with the least cargo space.
What Do Independent Reviewers Say?
TrueCar steers Corolla Cross shoppers toward the hybrid, noting that the gas version handles errands fine but runs short of breath on hills, which matters on mountain passes around Bozeman. On the Honda side, owners surveyed by Kelley Blue Book rate the 2027 HR‑V above average for its class, with a 4.4 out of 5 for reliability.
Honda HR‑V or Toyota Corolla Cross: Which One Should You Buy?
- Choose the HR‑V if you want the stronger IIHS safety rating, more cargo room behind the rear seats, AWD available on every trim, or extended roadside assistance coverage.
- Choose the Corolla Cross if a hybrid with standard AWD is a must have, since that is one thing the HR‑V cannot match, or if a lower starting price and more horsepower matter more to you than crash test margin.
Test Drive the Honda HR‑V at Denny Menholt Honda in Bozeman
See the HR‑V's Real Time AWD, Honda Sensing safety tech, and Top Safety Pick+ rated design in person. Browse our new HR‑V inventory or schedule a test drive at Denny Menholt Honda in Bozeman.
Shop HR‑V Inventory Schedule a Test DriveHonda HR‑V vs Toyota Corolla Cross: Frequently Asked Questions
Does the Honda HR‑V come with all wheel drive?
Yes. Real Time AWD is available on every HR‑V trim, LX, Sport, and EX‑L, for $1,500 over the front wheel drive version.
Is there a hybrid version of the Honda HR‑V?
No. The HR‑V is sold with a 158 horsepower gas engine only in the US. The Corolla Cross offers a 196 horsepower hybrid with standard AWD, and Honda shoppers who want a hybrid SUV can look at the CR‑V Hybrid.
Is the Toyota Corolla Cross or Honda HR‑V more fuel efficient?
The Corolla Cross. The gas version is rated at up to 32 mpg combined and the hybrid at 42, compared with up to 28 mpg combined for the HR‑V.
Which is more powerful, HR‑V or Corolla Cross?
The Corolla Cross. The gas model makes 169 horsepower and the hybrid makes 196, compared with 158 for the HR‑V.
Which has the better crash test rating, HR‑V or Corolla Cross?
The HR‑V. It earned a 2026 IIHS Top Safety Pick+, the organization's highest award, while the Corolla Cross earned a Top Safety Pick under the 2025 criteria and did not receive a 2026 award.
Which has more cargo space, HR‑V or Corolla Cross?
The HR‑V offers 24.4 cubic feet behind the rear seats and 55.1 cubic feet with them folded. The gas Corolla Cross offers 24.0 to 25.5 cubic feet behind the rear seats, and the hybrid drops to about 21.5 cubic feet.
Do the HR‑V and Corolla Cross have the same warranty?
Nearly. Both carry a 3 year/36,000 mile basic warranty and a 5 year/60,000 mile powertrain warranty. Toyota's ToyotaCare includes an extra year of free maintenance; Honda's Service Pass includes an extra year of roadside assistance.
Pricing shown reflects Honda's and Toyota's national starting MSRP per trim, excluding destination. Actual Denny Menholt Honda inventory, dealer fees, and installed packages may price a specific HR‑V above or below these figures, and Corolla Cross pricing should be confirmed with a Toyota dealer since the Corolla Cross is not sold at Denny Menholt Honda.